TOEFL TPO -1 Academic Discussion Writing Sample: Your professor is teaching a class on architecture. Write a post responding to the professor's question.
真实用户提交的答案,配合AI智能评估与反馈
共有 2 份用户提交的样本
开始免费练习题目概览
Professor
As a witness of history, historical buildings have non-renewable characteristics. However, some argue that it's more important for the government to build new housing than to preserve old and historical buildings to meet people's needs for modern life. What's your take?
Student A
Historic buildings are a valuable cultural asset and can be maintained for generations. Critic may argue that it is too expensive to restore such an old building, but that is not necessarily true. Restoration ultimately saves natural resources because most of the materials are recycled as part of the new building.
Student B
I agree with Adam. In many cases, older buildings use materials that are no longer available at any cost, such as giant beams made from a single old tree. Original wood paneling, stone walls, and so on, can last for generations if properly maintained. By contrast, modern buildings made from compressed plywood and other cheap alternatives only last a few decades at most. In other words, it may cost less in the short run to erect a new building, but a historical building may require less money to maintain in the long run.
用户样本与评估结果
用户样本
From my perspective, I hold the point that preserving the old and historical buildings can gain more profit than building new buildings. To elaborate, old and historical buildings contain a great amount of value for historical meanings. The government spends money on preserve them can not only keep the city has more cultures but also can gain great profit from attracting tourists to visit the city. For example, Beijing is the capital of China, and it is also famous for its historical events. My friend Judy has been to Beijing last summer and she had a deep impression about the great-preserved Palace Museum. The Chinese government spends money on preserving the Palace Museum years and years which attribute to attracting more and more tourists all over the world to come and visit, and the government gain more profit than the money spends on preserving. Had it not been for the great preserving of Beijing, the government would not have had the chance to gain the great profit from tourists. In conclusion, I advocate that it is important for the governments to spend money on preserve the old and historical buildings.
评估结果
1. 子项得分
-
Relevance and Contribution to Discussion: 4.5
-
Clarity and Elaboration of Viewpoint: 4.0
-
Language Use and Grammar: 4.0
2. 预估分数
- 27
3. 任务完成度
总体来说,你的文章完成了任务要求,但还有一些可以改进的地方。首先,在表达观点时,可以尝试提供更多具体的例子来支持你的观点。此外,文章中存在一些语法错误和用词不当的地方,需要进行修改。
改进示例1: 原文:The government spends money on preserve them can not only keep the city has more cultures but also can gain great profit from attracting tourists to visit the city. 修改后:The government's investment in preserving these historical buildings not only helps maintain the city's cultural heritage but also generates significant revenue by attracting tourists.
改进示例2: 原文:My friend Judy has been to Beijing last summer and she had a deep impression about the great-preserved Palace Museum. 修改后:My friend Judy visited Beijing last summer, and she was deeply impressed by the well-preserved Palace Museum.
4. 文章结构与组织
从组织结构上看,你的文章基本上遵循了引言、正文和结论的结构。然而,在段落之间缺乏明确的过渡和连接。为了使文章更加流畅,建议在段落之间添加过渡句子,并确保每个段落都集中讨论一个特定的观点。
改进示例1: 原文:To elaborate, old and historical buildings contain a great amount of value for historical meanings. 修改后:To elaborate on this point, old and historical buildings hold significant historical value.
改进示例2: 原文:In conclusion, I advocate that it is important for the governments to spend money on preserve the old and historical buildings. 修改后:In conclusion, I firmly believe that it is crucial for governments to invest in preserving old and historical buildings for their cultural, economic, and environmental benefits.
5. 语法批改
From my perspective, I hold the point that preserving the old and historical buildings can gain more profit than building new buildings. To elaborate, old and historical buildings contain a great amount of value for historical meanings. The government spends money on preserve them can not only keep the city has more cultures but also can gain great profit from attracting tourists to visit the city. For example, Beijing is the capital of China, and it is also famous for its historical events. My friend Judy has been to Beijing last summer and, and(comma between independent clauses) she had a deep impression about the great-preserved Palace Museum. The Chinese government spends money on preserving the Palace Museum years and years which attribute to attracting more and more tourists all over the world to come and visit, and the government gain more profit than the money spends on preserving. Had it not been for the great preserving of Beijing, the government would not have had the chance to gain the great profit from tourists. In conclusion, I advocate that it is important for the governments to spend money on preserve the old and historical buildings.
Section Title: 6 文章修订
In my opinion, preserving historical buildings offers greater benefits than constructing new ones. Old and historical structures hold immense historical significance, and investing in their preservation not only enriches a city's cultural heritage but also generates substantial revenue through tourism. For instance, Beijing, China's capital, is renowned for its rich history. A friend of mine visited the well-preserved Palace Museum last summer and was deeply impressed by its grandeur. The Chinese government's continuous investment in maintaining the Palace Museum has attracted a growing number of tourists from around the world, yielding profits that far exceed preservation costs. Without such diligent preservation efforts, the government would miss out on this lucrative opportunity. Therefore, I firmly believe that governments should prioritize the preservation of old and historical buildings. (130 words)
From In my opinion, preserving historical buildings offers greater benefits than constructing new ones (Changed "From my perspective, I hold the point that preserving the old and historical buildings can gain that" to "In my opinion" for a more profit than building new buildings. To elaborate, old and historical buildings contain natural tone). Old and historical structures hold immense historical significance (Rephrased "contain a great amount of value for historical meanings. The government spends money on preserve them can meanings" to make it clearer), and investing in their preservation not only keep the city has more cultures enriches a city's cultural heritage but also can gain great profit generates substantial revenue through tourism (Reworded to improve clarity and flow). For instance, Beijing, China's capital, is renowned for its rich history (Simplified the sentence for better flow). A friend of mine visited the well-preserved Palace Museum last summer and was deeply impressed by its grandeur (Revised to improve sentence structure). The Chinese government's continuous investment in maintaining the Palace Museum has attracted a growing number of tourists from attracting tourists to visit the city. For example, Beijing is the capital of China, and around the world, yielding profits that far exceed preservation costs (Reworded to improve clarity and flow). Without such diligent preservation efforts, the government would miss out on this lucrative opportunity (Simplified the sentence for better flow). Therefore, I firmly believe that governments should prioritize the preservation of old and historical buildings (Changed "I advocate that it is also famous for its historical events. My friend Judy has been to Beijing last summer and she had a deep impression about the great-preserved Palace Museum. The Chinese government spends money on preserving the Palace Museum years and years which attribute to attracting more and more tourists all over the world to come and visit, and the government gain more profit than the money spends on preserving. Had it not been for the great preserving of Beijing, the government would not have had the chance to gain the great profit from tourists. In conclusion, I advocate that it is important for the important" to "I firmly believe that governments to spend money on preserve the old and historical buildings.should prioritize" for a stronger conclusion).
8 思维导图
- 主题: 保护历史建筑的重要性
- 历史意义
- 文化遗产丰富
- 城市特色
- 经济效益
- 旅游业收入增加
- 投资回报高于成本
- 政府责任与政策支持
- 高效的保护措施
- 吸引全球游客
9 关键词
| Word | Phonetic Symbol | Part of Speech | English definition | Simplified Chinese translation | Sample sentences |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| preservation | /ˌprɛzərˈveɪʃən/ | noun | the act of keeping something in its original state | 保护、保存 | The government is committed to the preservation of historical buildings. |
| significance | /sɪɡˈnɪfɪkəns/ | noun | the importance or meaning of something | 意义、重要性 | The historical significance of these buildings cannot be overstated. |
| cultural heritage | /ˈkʌltʃərəl ˈhɛrɪtɪdʒ/ | noun | the art, traditions, and beliefs that a society considers important and wants to preserve for future generations | 文化遗产 | Preserving historical buildings helps to maintain a city's cultural heritage. |
| revenue | /ˈrɛvənju/ | noun | income, especially when of an organization and of a substantial nature | 收入、营收 | The preservation of historical buildings generates substantial revenue through tourism. |
| investment | /ɪnˈvɛstmənt/ | noun | the action or process of investing money for profit or material result | 投资 | The government's investment in maintaining the Palace Museum has paid off. |
| preservation costs | /ˌprɛzərˈveɪʃən kɒsts/ | noun | the expenses associated with keeping something in its original state | 保护成本 | The profits generated from tourism far exceed the preservation costs. |
| lucrative | /ˈluːkrətɪv/ | adjective | producing a great deal of profit | 获利丰厚的 | Preserving historical buildings can be a lucrative opportunity for governments. |
| prioritize | /praɪˈɒrətaɪz/ | verb | -to decide which items are most important and deal with them first | -优先考虑、优先处理 | -Governments should prioritize the preservation of old and historical buildings. |
Section Title: 6 文章修订
In my opinion, preserving historical buildings offers greater benefits than constructing new ones. Old and historical structures hold immense historical significance, and investing in their preservation not only enriches a city's cultural heritage but also generates substantial revenue through tourism. For instance, Beijing, China's capital, is renowned for its rich history. A friend of mine visited the well-preserved Palace Museum last summer and was deeply impressed by its grandeur. The Chinese government's continuous investment in maintaining the Palace Museum has attracted a growing number of tourists from around the world, yielding profits that far exceed preservation costs. Without such diligent preservation efforts, the government would miss out on this lucrative opportunity. Therefore, I firmly believe that governments should prioritize the preservation of old and historical buildings.
学术讨论评分标准
托福学术讨论任务基于ETS官方评分标准进行评估。AI评估系统从多个维度分析每个回答。
相关性与贡献
回答是否针对问题并为讨论做出有意义的贡献?
语言运用
语法准确性、词汇丰富度和句式结构质量。
论述与支撑
观点是否充分展开,是否有具体例子和清晰推理支撑?
回答中的常见模式
基于对该题目用户提交内容的分析,以下是在学生回答中观察到的常见模式。
很多学生能清楚表达观点,但缺乏具体的论据支撑。
高分回答会直接引用阅读段落和其他发言者的观点。
更高分的回答使用多样化的句式结构和学术词汇。
时间管理是关键因素——匆忙完成的回答在论述发展方面得分较低。
学习建议
在开始写作前仔细阅读题目,理清问题的所有组成部分。
在回答中引用阅读段落和其他同学的观点。
使用具体例子来支持你的主要论点——避免笼统的表述。
目标字数120-150词。更长的回答不一定更好;清晰度和针对性更重要。
进行限时练习(10分钟),在考试条件下提升写作流畅度。
常见问题
什么是托福学术讨论任务?
学术讨论任务如何评分?
本页面上的用户样本是什么?
AI评估的准确度如何?
如何练习这道学术讨论题目?
学术讨论回答应该多长?
相关托福学术讨论题目
All TOEFL Writing Samples
Browse all user-submitted TOEFL writing samples with AI evaluation
TOEFL Academic Discussion Guide
Learn strategies and tips for the Academic Discussion writing task
TOEFL Writing Guide
Complete guide to all TOEFL writing task types and scoring
TOEFL Speaking Guide
Master all TOEFL speaking tasks with expert strategies
TOEFL Reading Guide
Strategies for TOEFL reading comprehension tasks
TOEFL Listening Guide
Tips and practice for TOEFL listening comprehension